Never run out of cookies!

Choose from our delightful monthly cookie subscriptions: opt for a sweet surprise every month for 3, 6, or 12 months, or craft your own custom subscription with our 12 year-round flavors delivered every 2, 4, or 6 weeks. Whether you crave classic favorites or adventurous new tastes, we’ve got the perfect cookie experience just for you!

Clear all

7 products

Filter and sort

Filter and sort

7 products

Clear all
Clear all

7 products

Never Run Out Of Cookies!

  • Cookie of The Month

    1 dozen cookies, 1 flavor each month

    • available in 3, 6, or 12 month option
    • select "one time option vs autorenew"
    • control delivery date or skip months in portal

  • Build Your Own Subscription

    Endless Possibilities

    • you pick the flavors from 12 always available flavors
    • you pick how many stacks
    • you pick from 2, 4, or 6 week delivery
    • control delivery date or skip months in portal

  • Snackin' Sampler Club

    12 cookies, 6 flavors

    • available in 3, 6, or 12 month option
    • select "one time option vs autorenew"
    • control delivery date or skip months in portal

1 3

Gift Questions

Do you include a gift message?

For you? Sure thing! Just indicate this is a gift at check out and it will give you space to leave a short note, which we write by hand! (no emojis please!)

Can I order for a future date?

Sure thing! Indicate the delivery date for the first box at checkout and we'll adjust the subsequent orders for timing in your portal!

How does this bill?

Great question! With Cookie of the Month or Snacking Sampler, you will be charged at the beginning of the series. Example 3 month subscription will bill full amount upon your order, then 2 more orders will generate, but they will be zero dollar orders (so we can ship and you can get tracking!) If you select "one time only" if will not bill again, if you select "auto renew" it will bill after the 3 month series

How fresh will they be?

We will ship the day these are baked and we ship to arrive in two days.

How long will they last?

There are care instructions included with each package in terms of best storage practices to keep these cookies a fresh as possible!

Do you have a same day option?

Great question! We can send cookies and some gift options same day from our bakery via third party courier! Order here Beware, the local delivery option is limited and determined by third party courier. If you aren't familiar with Boston, sometimes it's easier to ship the gift will get to a secure location, rather than trying to coordinate delivery, we promise to ship the next possible shipping day.

Can I ask more questions?

Of course! We really recommend reaching out to us via chat or email (hello@topshelfcookies.com). We will get back to you ASAP, chances are we're baking cookies and it's hard to take a phone call!